Home » blogging » class in second life

class in second life


I am currently reading bell hooks’ Where We Stand: Class Matters (review coming soon). In one of the book’s essays, “Class and the Politics of Living Simply,” I came across this passage:

Propaganda in advertising and in the culture as a whole assures the poor that they can be one with those who are more materially privileged if they own the same products. It helps sustain the false notion that ours is a classless society.

I was surprised to realize that it made me think about Second Life—the “3D online digital world,” as the website has it. If consumer culture and the belief that owning the same products as the upper classes gives people the impression that they are part of the ruling class, how much more in an online environment where everyone can—without too much effort—have pretty much equality in body, clothes, houses, etc.? Why would I ever leave Second Life when my first-life body isn’t perfect, my clothes are old, my house is a run-down apartment, or worse? Seems like Web 3.0 could make the illusion of a class-free society even more virulent. Or is it, rather, that Web 3.0 will actually have a democratizing effect? But, only if there is equal access for everyone?

There are, of course, a host of questions one can ask about Second Life and other online environments, and most of them have probably been asked before. Perhaps these are the musings of an aging book lover who likes the feel of paper in his hands and is needlessly worried about the loss of in-person human interaction that the web is creating. (For example—and I realize some people feel differently—no matter how much online chatting I do, I can’t call someone a “friend” until I’ve had at least some fact-to-face interaction with them.) I’m sure I’m ridiculously retrograde, a veritable troglodyte. Meanwhile, I think we as individuals and as a society need to be thinking about the impacts of the internet and its evolution on issues like race, class, gender, and more.

I’d love to hear what you think. Enlighten my dark mind.



  1. someuneducatedguy says:

    I fear that the ideal of the web becoming a democratizing and leveling tool is just that-a pipe dream. Even though technology becomes more powerful and inexpensive every year there is still a huge digital divide and many may never be able to cross that chasm. Web 3.0 requires cutting edge technology and high-speed access. Content more often than not has a price attached. For those who are comfortable financially this access is just another small monthly bill. For many it’s an impossible financial hurdle. Oh, I’d prefer to characterize you as a somewhat anachronistic rather than a troglodyte.


  2. jl says:

    I realize this post is super old, but it is something I’ve thought a lot about: I think the thing to remember about the internet is what it can potentially do to/for our- the world’s- collective consciousness. Also, now there’s this: http://laptop.org/en/vision/index.shtml –so. The world community can and will be connected- what we chose to do with that connectedness will certainly determine if not define our future… the potentials are huge. Having said that, I’m all for the tactility and essense of a bound volume. As cliche as it is, there’s just nothing like curling up with a good book, or sticking one in your pocket for your bus/bart/train ride into town. My bibliophilic tendoncies aren’t at all threatened by the encroaching technology… in fact, I anticipate a huge, generic return to reading; a kind of reaction to all the overstimulation that we’ve all been exposed to lately… (can you tell I slung tome for half my life, or what?)

  3. jl says:

    essence. jesus

  4. halshop says:

    Jl–I hope you’re right . . . and I think you are.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: